| Black | 13 | Matthew Elliott | 2016 | Cambridge-South Dorchester | East New Market | MD | USA | RHP | 8.50 |
Shenandoah University
|
| Premium Content |
| Cardinal | 8 | Brandon Laventure | 2016 | Notre Dame Bishop Gibbons Scho | Schenectady | NY | USA | OF | 8.00 |
|
| Premium Content |
| Black | 8 | Elliott McKee | 2016 | Westfield | Centreville | VA | USA | LHP | 8.00 |
University of Mary Washington
|
| Premium Content |
| Cardinal | 20 | Danny Roth | 2016 | Hall | West Hartford | CT | USA | SS | 8.00 |
Roger Williams University
|
| Premium Content |
| Cardinal | 22 | Joe Sfreddo | 2016 | Saint John Paul The Great | Dumfries | VA | USA | LHP | 6.50 |
|
| Premium Content |
| Black | 24 | Tyler Solomon | 2017 | Battlefield | Haymarket | VA | USA | C | 9.50 |
William & Mary/Florida Southwestern State College
|
| Premium Content |